consolidation: R1 — decide opensin-ai-cli merge vs split

[Delqhi]

Consolidation ticket R1 — opensin-ai-cli vs OpenSIN-Code

Tracker: OpenSIN-overview/docs/FOLLOWUPS.md § R1

Co-owner: Team-SIN-Code-Core.

Problem

Two Rust coding CLIs in the same org:

• OpenSIN-AI/opensin-ai-cli — 70 files / 34.6k lines / 9 crates
• OpenSIN-AI/OpenSIN-Code — canonical autonomous TS CLI, also ships a Rust engine (71 files / 37.7k lines)

Currently nothing prevents a new contributor from landing Rust work in the wrong repo.

Decision required

1. Merge the useful crates of opensin-ai-cli into OpenSIN-Code/crates/* and archive opensin-ai-cli with a redirect README, OR
2. Split responsibilities — e.g. OpenSIN-Code = TS frontend + orchestration, opensin-ai-cli = Rust engine only. Document the split in OpenSIN-overview/docs/CANONICAL-REPOS.md and remove the rationalization flag.

Acceptance criteria

• Crate-by-crate comparison matrix in docs/consolidation/R1-diff.md
• Written decision with rationale (performance, runtime model, user-facing surface)
• If merge: migration PR(s) landing the useful crates into OpenSIN-Code/crates/*
• If split: updated CANONICAL-REPOS.md declaring both as canonical with non-overlapping roles; flag removed
• OpenSIN-overview/docs/FOLLOWUPS.md § R1 status changed to DONE
• Companion README-banner issue on opensin-ai-cli closed

Unblocks

Sprint 1 heartbeat work in opensin-ai-agent-feature-spec.md § 2.1.

[github-actions]

🤖 Cloud Coder Dispatched\n\n| Field | Value |\n|-------|-------|\n| Agent | fullstack |\n| Branch | feat/issue-1116-consolidation--r1---decide-opensin-ai-cl |\n| Priority | high |\n| Dispatched | 2026-04-18T22:54:23Z |\n| Dispatcher | GitHub Action |\n\n⏳ Cloud Coder: Clone repo, checkout branch, implement, commit, push, create PR.

[github-actions]

🤖 Cloud Coder Dispatched\n\n| Field | Value |\n|-------|-------|\n| Agent | fullstack |\n| Branch | feat/issue-1116-consolidation--r1---decide-opensin-ai-cl |\n| Priority | high |\n| Dispatched | 2026-04-18T23:40:33Z |\n| Dispatcher | GitHub Action |\n\n⏳ Cloud Coder: Clone repo, checkout branch, implement, commit, push, create PR.

[github-actions]

🤖 Cloud Coder Dispatched\n\n| Field | Value |\n|-------|-------|\n| Agent | fullstack |\n| Branch | feat/issue-1116-consolidation--r1---decide-opensin-ai-cl |\n| Priority | high |\n| Dispatched | 2026-04-19T01:11:11Z |\n| Dispatcher | GitHub Action |\n\n⏳ Cloud Coder: Clone repo, checkout branch, implement, commit, push, create PR.

[Delqhi]

Wave 4 update — consolidation-ticket owners please read

Context from the overview repo on 2026-04-19 (commits on PR overview#46):

• L1 (Delqhi link sweep) is DONE. Live gh search code turned up 0 actionable hits org-wide. The sweep assumption was wrong; reality cleared itself.
• L2 (archived-repo refs) has live evidence: 26 hits for A2A-SIN-Coding-CEO, 1 for OpenSIN-onboarding. Procedure in FOLLOWUPS § L2.
• M2 (oh-my-sin aggregator) is partial-done. templates/oh-my-sin.json is now the SSOT. 17 teams, 87 agents referenced. The proposed nightly workflow installs via install.sh.
• S2 (6 A2A-SIN-Code- scaffolds)* audit complete in docs/S2-DEAD-REPO-AUDIT.md. Decision matrix is gated by this R1 ticket.

Decision deadline: 2026-04-22 18:00 CET

If R1 is not resolved by that time, the S2 fallback (collapse 6 scaffolds to 1) auto-applies so T-0 has a clean story. No launch is blocked by R1 itself — but keeping it undecided forces a worse S2 branch.

Reference graph

• Launch plan: LAUNCH-CHECKLIST.md
• Command Center issue: overview#47
• CEO directive: overview#40
• Waiver log: governance/WAIVER-LOG.md

[github-actions]

🤖 Cloud Coder Dispatched\n\n| Field | Value |\n|-------|-------|\n| Agent | fullstack |\n| Branch | feat/issue-1116-consolidation--r1---decide-opensin-ai-cl |\n| Priority | high |\n| Dispatched | 2026-04-19T04:25:18Z |\n| Dispatcher | GitHub Action |\n\n⏳ Cloud Coder: Clone repo, checkout branch, implement, commit, push, create PR.

[github-actions]

🤖 Cloud Coder Dispatched\n\n| Field | Value |\n|-------|-------|\n| Agent | fullstack |\n| Branch | feat/issue-1116-consolidation--r1---decide-opensin-ai-cl |\n| Priority | high |\n| Dispatched | 2026-04-19T06:16:06Z |\n| Dispatcher | GitHub Action |\n\n⏳ Cloud Coder: Clone repo, checkout branch, implement, commit, push, create PR.

[github-actions]

🤖 Cloud Coder Dispatched\n\n| Field | Value |\n|-------|-------|\n| Agent | fullstack |\n| Branch | feat/issue-1116-consolidation--r1---decide-opensin-ai-cl |\n| Priority | high |\n| Dispatched | 2026-04-19T07:50:58Z |\n| Dispatcher | GitHub Action |\n\n⏳ Cloud Coder: Clone repo, checkout branch, implement, commit, push, create PR.

[github-actions]

🤖 Cloud Coder Dispatched\n\n| Field | Value |\n|-------|-------|\n| Agent | fullstack |\n| Branch | feat/issue-1116-consolidation--r1---decide-opensin-ai-cl |\n| Priority | high |\n| Dispatched | 2026-04-19T08:49:44Z |\n| Dispatcher | GitHub Action |\n\n⏳ Cloud Coder: Clone repo, checkout branch, implement, commit, push, create PR.

[github-actions]

🤖 Cloud Coder Dispatched\n\n| Field | Value |\n|-------|-------|\n| Agent | fullstack |\n| Branch | feat/issue-1116-consolidation--r1---decide-opensin-ai-cl |\n| Priority | high |\n| Dispatched | 2026-04-19T09:40:11Z |\n| Dispatcher | GitHub Action |\n\n⏳ Cloud Coder: Clone repo, checkout branch, implement, commit, push, create PR.

[github-actions]

🤖 Cloud Coder Dispatched\n\n| Field | Value |\n|-------|-------|\n| Agent | fullstack |\n| Branch | feat/issue-1116-consolidation--r1---decide-opensin-ai-cl |\n| Priority | high |\n| Dispatched | 2026-04-19T10:25:45Z |\n| Dispatcher | GitHub Action |\n\n⏳ Cloud Coder: Clone repo, checkout branch, implement, commit, push, create PR.

[github-actions]

🤖 Cloud Coder Dispatched\n\n| Field | Value |\n|-------|-------|\n| Agent | fullstack |\n| Branch | feat/issue-1116-consolidation--r1---decide-opensin-ai-cl |\n| Priority | high |\n| Dispatched | 2026-04-19T11:10:47Z |\n| Dispatcher | GitHub Action |\n\n⏳ Cloud Coder: Clone repo, checkout branch, implement, commit, push, create PR.