diff --git a/classes/helpers/FrmAppHelper.php b/classes/helpers/FrmAppHelper.php
index fa9234fec0..b090246702 100644
--- a/classes/helpers/FrmAppHelper.php
+++ b/classes/helpers/FrmAppHelper.php
@@ -2781,23 +2781,21 @@ public static function get_unique_key( $name, $table_name, $column, $id = 0, $nu
 			$key = self::generate_new_key( $num_chars );
 		}
 
-		$key = self::prevent_numeric_and_reserved_keys( $key );
-
-		$similar_keys = FrmDb::get_col(
-			$table_name,
-			array(
-				$column . ' like%' => $key,
-				'ID !'             => $id,
-			),
-			$column
-		);
+		$key          = self::prevent_numeric_and_reserved_keys( $key );
+		$similar_keys = self::get_similar_keys( $key, $table_name, $column, $id );
 
 		// Create a unique field id if it has already been used.
 		if ( ! in_array( $key, $similar_keys, true ) ) {
 			return $key;
 		}
 
-		$key = self::maybe_truncate_key_before_appending( $column, $key );
+		$truncated_key = self::maybe_truncate_key_before_appending( $column, $key );
+
+		if ( $truncated_key !== $key ) {
+			// Keys already created from the truncated key aren't in the list loaded for the full key.
+			$key          = $truncated_key;
+			$similar_keys = self::get_similar_keys( $key, $table_name, $column, $id );
+		}
 
 		/**
 		 * Allow for a custom separator between the attempted key and the generated suffix.
@@ -2818,6 +2816,25 @@ public static function get_unique_key( $name, $table_name, $column, $id = 0, $nu
 		return $key_check;
 	}
 
+	/**
+	 * @param string $key
+	 * @param string $table_name
+	 * @param string $column
+	 * @param int    $id
+	 *
+	 * @return array<string>
+	 */
+	private static function get_similar_keys( $key, $table_name, $column, $id ) {
+		return FrmDb::get_col(
+			$table_name,
+			array(
+				$column . ' like%' => $key,
+				'ID !'             => $id,
+			),
+			$column
+		);
+	}
+
 	/**
 	 * Avoid trying to append to a really long key,
 	 * The database limit is 100 for form and field keys so we want to avoid getting too close.
diff --git a/tests/phpunit/misc/test_FrmAppHelper.php b/tests/phpunit/misc/test_FrmAppHelper.php
index 84d0864862..c9f77110ec 100644
--- a/tests/phpunit/misc/test_FrmAppHelper.php
+++ b/tests/phpunit/misc/test_FrmAppHelper.php
@@ -522,6 +522,22 @@ public function test_get_unique_key() {
 		$this->assertNotSame( $super_long_form_key, $unique_key );
 	}
 
+	public function test_get_unique_key_increments_for_truncated_long_key() {
+		$table_name = 'frm_forms';
+		$column     = 'form_key';
+		$long_key   = str_repeat( 'a', 75 );
+		$truncated  = substr( $long_key, 0, 60 );
+
+		$this->factory->form->create( array( 'form_key' => $long_key ) );
+
+		$first = FrmAppHelper::get_unique_key( $long_key, $table_name, $column );
+		$this->assertSame( $truncated . '2', $first );
+		$this->factory->form->create( array( 'form_key' => $first ) );
+
+		$second = FrmAppHelper::get_unique_key( $long_key, $table_name, $column );
+		$this->assertSame( $truncated . '3', $second, 'The suffix should skip keys already created from the truncated key.' );
+	}
+
 	private function add_field_to_form( $form_id, $field_key ) {
 		$type = 'text';
 		$this->factory->field->create( compact( 'type', 'form_id', 'field_key' ) );