Problem
The review skill requires an AskUserQuestion tool and exits immediately when the host does not expose one.
Codex Desktop sessions can lack both a native AskUserQuestion tool and an MCP variant. In that configuration, the workflow cannot perform a code review even when the user has explicitly authorized a noninteractive review and fixes.
Reproduction
- Run the GStack
review skill in a Codex Desktop session with no AskUserQuestion tool registered.
- The skill reaches its compatibility gate and reports
BLOCKED — AskUserQuestion unavailable.
- No review runs.
Expected behavior
Provide a Codex-compatible fallback, such as:
- continue without interactive prompts when the user explicitly authorizes execution
- use the host's available user-input primitive when present
- reserve a hard block for review states that genuinely require a user decision
Impact
This turns an advisory interactive dependency into a total failure for automated review and remediation in Codex Desktop.
Problem
The
reviewskill requires anAskUserQuestiontool and exits immediately when the host does not expose one.Codex Desktop sessions can lack both a native
AskUserQuestiontool and an MCP variant. In that configuration, the workflow cannot perform a code review even when the user has explicitly authorized a noninteractive review and fixes.Reproduction
reviewskill in a Codex Desktop session with no AskUserQuestion tool registered.BLOCKED — AskUserQuestion unavailable.Expected behavior
Provide a Codex-compatible fallback, such as:
Impact
This turns an advisory interactive dependency into a total failure for automated review and remediation in Codex Desktop.