Seen on dev@debffabf6.
What happened
Both belts pass the parent process environment to bash commands run for a model. When OPENROUTER_API_KEY is exported, the child receives it. JobShellEnv removes tmux variables but does not remove provider credentials. A key stored only in the profile is read by config.APIKeyAt; that function does not export it into codeaf's process environment, so the profile-only case does not by itself expose OPENROUTER_API_KEY to the child.
Replication
Deterministic (no model). Save as internal/exec/bare/shell_env_key_test.go and run go test ./internal/exec/bare -run TestAProviderKeyDoesNotReachAModelsShell -count=1:
package bare
import (
"strings"
"testing"
)
// A provider key in codeaf's environment must not reach a model's shell.
func TestAProviderKeyDoesNotReachAModelsShell(t *testing.T) {
t.Setenv("OPENROUTER_API_KEY", "probe-not-a-key")
for _, entry := range StreamingEnv() {
if strings.HasPrefix(entry, "OPENROUTER_API_KEY=") {
t.Fatal("OPENROUTER_API_KEY reaches the environment of the model's shell")
}
}
}
Today it fails with OPENROUTER_API_KEY reaches the environment of the model's shell. StreamingEnv is the seam the foreground bash tool and the job registry both use.
Field (real models). With OPENROUTER_API_KEY exported, in a throwaway repository: codeaf do --json 'run exactly this shell command and report its output: if [ -n "${OPENROUTER_API_KEY+x}" ]; then echo key-set; else echo key-unset; fi'. Under a minute, a fraction of a cent. Today the reply reports key-set. The command never prints the value.
Where
At dev@debffabf6, internal/exec/bare/streaming.go:120, StreamingEnv, starts from os.Environ(); internal/exec/tools.go:1594 and :1938, JobShellEnv, preserve provider keys. internal/config/apikey.go:60, APIKeyAt, reads a profile key without setting an environment variable.
The fix
Give model-run child processes a scrubbed environment that removes provider credentials by default. Provide a deliberate opt-in pass-through for a task that genuinely needs one.
Acceptance
- e2e: a bash call on each belt prints
key-unset for a provider key inherited by codeaf unless an explicit pass-through was granted.
- Unit: environment filtering covers exported and profile-only keys without logging secret values.
- Document the opt-in and record the former inheritance in
invalidates.
Seen on
dev@debffabf6.What happened
Both belts pass the parent process environment to bash commands run for a model. When
OPENROUTER_API_KEYis exported, the child receives it.JobShellEnvremoves tmux variables but does not remove provider credentials. A key stored only in the profile is read byconfig.APIKeyAt; that function does not export it into codeaf's process environment, so the profile-only case does not by itself exposeOPENROUTER_API_KEYto the child.Replication
Deterministic (no model). Save as
internal/exec/bare/shell_env_key_test.goand rungo test ./internal/exec/bare -run TestAProviderKeyDoesNotReachAModelsShell -count=1:Today it fails with
OPENROUTER_API_KEY reaches the environment of the model's shell.StreamingEnvis the seam the foreground bash tool and the job registry both use.Field (real models). With
OPENROUTER_API_KEYexported, in a throwaway repository:codeaf do --json 'run exactly this shell command and report its output: if [ -n "${OPENROUTER_API_KEY+x}" ]; then echo key-set; else echo key-unset; fi'. Under a minute, a fraction of a cent. Today the reply reportskey-set. The command never prints the value.Where
At
dev@debffabf6,internal/exec/bare/streaming.go:120,StreamingEnv, starts fromos.Environ();internal/exec/tools.go:1594and:1938,JobShellEnv, preserve provider keys.internal/config/apikey.go:60,APIKeyAt, reads a profile key without setting an environment variable.The fix
Give model-run child processes a scrubbed environment that removes provider credentials by default. Provide a deliberate opt-in pass-through for a task that genuinely needs one.
Acceptance
key-unsetfor a provider key inherited by codeaf unless an explicit pass-through was granted.invalidates.