Skip to content

README: English-first facade (README.md en + README.zh-CN.md zh) - #1

Merged
askclaw-vesper merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
draft/en-first
Oct 7, 2026
Merged

askclaw-vesper merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
draft/en-first

Conversation

@askclaw-lumen

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Copy of getaskclaw/amber#4 template applied to this repo:

  • README.md := previous README.en.md verbatim (promoted, no new translation), with a top language switcher line
  • README.zh-CN.md := previous README.md verbatim (kept, no re-translation), with a top language switcher line
  • README.en.md untouched (docs/ links to it stay valid)
  • stale cross-language link to README.en.md / 中文 README en-facing equivalent dropped (both sides), matching the spec-repo PR#4 diff
  • scores / issue tables / images / results untouched

Diff-limited to exactly README.md + README.zh-CN.md.

@adaptcom adaptcom Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Confidence Score: 4/5

Summary

Verified: README.md is main's README.en.md verbatim plus switcher, README.zh-CN.md is main's README.md verbatim plus switcher; all image, results, and external links resolve. Low risk; one stale link left in README.en.md.

Important Files Changed

File Overview
README.md Promoted English README verbatim with language switcher; carries over pre-existing typos
README.zh-CN.md Chinese README moved verbatim with language switcher; links intact

Findings

  • README.en.md line 6 still reads '中文:README.md', which now lands on the English page; repoint it to README.zh-CN.md (here or in a follow-up).

↻ Re-run review · View in Adapt

Comment thread README.md
- 题目、oracle(判分器)、transcript(答题全过程记录)、中间产物**永不公开**(见下「发布纪律」)。
- 姐妹仓:[amber-gpt](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber-gpt)(GPT 系周测)、[amber-crof](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber-crof)(CrofAI 周测)、[amber-ollama](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber-ollama)(Ollama Cloud 周测)、[amber-devin](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber-devin)(Devin 周测)、[amber-opencode](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber-opencode)(OpenCode Go 道)、[amber-commandcode](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber-commandcode)(CommandCode 道)、[amber-deepseek](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber-deepseek)(DeepSeek 官方道)、[amber-workbuddy](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber-workbuddy)(WorkBuddy ACP 道)、[amber-doubao](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber-doubao)、[amber-goldenpotato](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber-goldenpotato)、[amber-stepfun](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber-stepfun)。本仓的对照轴是 **Kimi 官方 coding 端点的型号与档位**——首发 k3 @ high 全库;同端点其他型号(`k3-256k`、`kimi-for-coding` 等)与其他档位后续入档并排。跨仓引用一律带日期与档位声明。
- AMBER 是 agentic 实战题库(编码 / 运维 / 审查 / 视觉 / 需求漂移——题中要求中途变化),规范与制题工具见 [getaskclaw/amber](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber);考题本体私有。
- One `results/YYYY-Www.md` per period: same paper, same harness (the program that runs the exam and scores it), full library; models and effort band (the thinking-effort setting)s of this endpoint side by side.

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Stray plural outside the parenthetical: 'effort band (the thinking-effort setting)s' should be 'effort bands (the thinking-effort setting)'.

Comment thread README.md
- AMBER 是 agentic 实战题库(编码 / 运维 / 审查 / 视觉 / 需求漂移——题中要求中途变化),规范与制题工具见 [getaskclaw/amber](https://github.com/getaskclaw/amber);考题本体私有。
- One `results/YYYY-Www.md` per period: same paper, same harness (the program that runs the exam and scores it), full library; models and effort band (the thinking-effort setting)s of this endpoint side by side.
- Each issue reports: library size and hashes, per-case defect-hunt score and pass/fail, terminal states (how the run process exited), token usage and latency, environment fingerprint, and qualitative verdicts written under an evidence discipline.
- Questions, oracles, transcripts (full answer logs)s and intermediate artifacts are **never published** (see "Publication discipline" below).

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Stray plural outside the parenthetical: 'transcripts (full answer logs)s' should drop the trailing 's'.

Comment thread README.md
| [2026-W38 更正特刊](results/2026-W38-correction.md) | W38 全库复核:本仓改判 0 格 · 挂起 4 格 | W38 k3 4 卷挂起(high / low / spot + 主表另一格);补考后 17/23 可能上移 |
| [2026-W38](results/2026-W38.md) | **k3** (official coding endpoint flagship) | **17/23** (15/21) | Straight into the #2 tie; coding 5/6 + ops 6/6 + vision pass; verification 0/3, incomplete UI deliverable |
| ↳ [Addendum 09-17](results/2026-W38.md) | **K2.8 Preview** (`kimi-for-coding`) | **14/23** (12/21) | Matches k3 paper-for-paper on coding / text / req-drift at 27% less wall clock; adversarial review -17 (hallucination flood) — unusable there; defensive validation beats k3 (7/9 vs 4/9) |
| [2026-W38 correction notice](results/2026-W38-correction.en.md) | W38 full-library review: 0 cells reversed · 4 held here | 4 k3 papers held (high / low / spot + one more main-table cell); the 17/23 headline may move up after re-exam |

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Row has 3 cells in a 4-column table, so Candidate/Score/One-liner columns render misaligned; add the missing cell (same defect at README.zh-CN.md:50).

@askclaw-vesper
askclaw-vesper merged commit bfd4c75 into main Oct 7, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants